This has been an incredibly difficult year for me, although at the moment it really doesn't seem so. While I've been quite busy this year, and a lot has changed, I feel like I've been stuffed with cotton wool and left out in the rain to turn to felt. Immobile, grey, and slightly musty. I can only assume that stress has caused me to drain out and block most of the year so that only the last month--which has been mostly work and frozen pizzas--comes to mind. It has not been made any easier by the recent release of a new Tori Amos album.
The one language that I shared with my father was
music. One of my first memories is holding my head against one of his massive Stonehengian speakers, listening to "Blackbird" off of the White Album, with him softly singing along. With all of the myriad difficulties I had with the man--and they were legion--I never once broke with the musical tradition that I learned in his house. I knew my father trusted me the day that he let me keep his album collection--hundreds and hundreds of perfectly preserved LPs--in my bedroom. He showed me the careful ritual of cleaning record and needle before carefully, gently, placing vinyl on turntable and then slowly dropping the needle. I listened to Pink Floyd's
Dark Side of the Moon on his massive studio quality headphones so many times that I can still hear the faint heartbeat , free of crackle and pop due to his fanatical care, on Side One, building to the vocals of "Breathe". He listened to music that was
good. Bach and Beethoven, Nitty Gritty Dirt Band and the Allman Brothers, what mattered was the
quality of the music, not the style or the popularity. I learned to play the cello. I learned to listen to music as a tapestry, a maze, an entire universe. I don't think it's exaggerating to say that listening to music is a skill, and it is one I have in spades, mostly thanks to my father the audiophile. Every now and then, even when we were barely speaking, one of us would say, "Listen to this" and play a song or two.
One of the only minor sources of dischord in this relationship was his stubborn idea that modern music was trash--one commonly held by parents about their childrens' music, but in his case, an opinion that I feel was unfortunately formed by the drek and sludge played on Top 40 radio stations in the past 10 years or more. Every now and then he would grudgingly admit that someone "wasn't bad"--usually an indie band my sister or I were playing, but occasionally someone a bit bigger. He liked the Red Hot Chili Pepper's version of "Rollercoaster".
Once, while listening to Tori Amos' "Under the Pink" at top volume (one of the ultimate benefits to living with a music lover for a father--my mother often told us to turn down our music, but my father never did, as he was likely to be playing something even louder than we were) he paused in my doorway to listen, and left with the comment "I would have listened to that when I was your age", which was pretty much an ultimate complement, coming as it did from someone who was convinced that popular music had pretty much topped out when he was "that age" that I currently was.
I tried to slip him Tori Amos after that, but he, like always, was grudging in his praise and complained that she "never sang anything
happy".
The release of her recent album was one I was excited about for many reasons, but the foremost was that everything that I'd heard about it pointed toward it being an album that I could finally give to him. He could enjoy it as music without being made uncomfortable by too much female politics (I could hardly blame him for being uncomfortable about songs referring to female masturbation, rape, and sex, as he had three adolescent daughters).
He died in September. The album was released in October. I bought it within a few days of its release. And it was exactly what I expected. My father would have liked this album a great deal.
So now I am in an interesting position. On one hand, I have a brilliant piece of work from the ground up. All of it--the arrangement, the lyrics, the musicians, the vocals, the engineering--is extremely good. Some of the songs are, frankly, amazing. The technical excellence alone makes the album worth purchasing. But listening to it is some ways an act of mourning, and in other ways it is a memorial, incense in the aural realm instead of the smoke of burnt offerings to the ancestors.
As anyone who has chanced upon the smallest blurb on this album has no doubt read, it is a sonic roadtrip of America. It is a post-9/11 trip, an explanation of the soul of the land that needs to be claimed by her people, a catalogue of interesting people met all over the country throughout the life of a woman named Scarlet, and a personal and sometimes cryptic journey taken by Scarlet. In other words, it's a Tori Amos album.
We begin with a fading porn star, and immediately move into a road trip to New Mexico. We meet a tarnished genius in "Carbon", threaten a wayward niece in "Don't Make Me Come to Texas", mourn a dead friend in "Taxi Ride", and experience a piece of the loss in New York during "I Can't See New York".
The chords of "A Sorta Fairytale" are like sweet, full drops of sweet Tokay. The vocal treatments of this album are perhaps her best, controlled and masterfully chorused. Those who complain of "histrionics" won't find that on this album, which shows more vocal restraint than on any of her albums. I have never heard better percussion on any of her albums, which the exception of the tracks Manu Katche contributed to on "Boys for Pele".
Like many of her songs, "Carbon" is perfect for driving alone on a desolate highway. ("iieee" and "yes, anastasia" are also good for this. "iieee" sounds exactly like driving through the res in New Mexico feels. I have friends who will confirm this. And I spent about 30 minutes driving along back roads in Wisconsin listening to "yes, anastasia" during August one summer.)
When she sings "the jacaranda tree/She's telling me/of the trouble you're in/just by the way She bends" in "Don't Make Me Come to Vegas" the words scale down beautifully around the sinuous bassline in a way that Joni Mitchell would be absolutely green with envy over. The deliciously
crunchy synth in "Sweet Sangria" goes directly to your spine, looks around with hard eyes, and instantly reminds you of desert scorpions. The same song has an unexpectedly beautiful piano chorus that breaks out of the song in a way that still surprises you on the fifth listen. I can't listen to "Sweet Virginia" without tearing up. It is a song about the lost youth of the land, and for someone who has seen a lot of destruction in places that should be holy, it is beautiful and sad.
"Wednesday" is pure Beatles pop, one of those Lennon/McCartney tunes that was mostly Lennon.
"Taxi Ride"--a song about a friend's death-- contains the cryptic, but enjoyable, lyrics "And I'm down to/Your last cigarette and/this "We are one" crap"
And the lyrics to "Crazy" are uncomfortably close to one of my own failed relationships that finally died in the desert.
But all the same, it is not my favorite album. Second favorite, possibly. Top three, probably. Depends on when you ask me, in what mood, and what the moon has done to me that month.
Boys for Pele is my favorite album of all time, and short of a major musical outburst of monumental proportions (always a possibility) I don't see that changing anytime soon. Still, from a technical sense, this is probably the best album Tori Amos has ever done. I am completely willing to admit that my attachment to
Pele is mostly emotional.
Scarlet is an awesome achievement, and will stand up extremely well .